Posted on — Leave a comment

Indonesia exports its talent, Korea captures the value: The K-pop lesson Jakarta can’t ignore

Hearts2Hearts’ debut under SM Entertainment in February 2025 (an eight-member girl group designed from the start for global audiences, with members drawn from multiple countries) was one of the more visible signals of how Korean entertainment has reshaped its talent acquisition model over the past five years. The group’s structure illustrates the dominant pattern in late-2020s K-pop: agencies in Seoul recruiting talent from across Asia, training them inside the Korean idol system, and releasing them through Korean entertainment IP infrastructure.

The parallel emergence of Indonesian artists, including No Na and others navigating between the Indonesian market and broader Asian opportunities, illustrates the other side of the same phenomenon. Indonesian talent is increasingly mobile. Indonesian entertainment industry capacity to capture the economic value of that mobility has not kept pace.

After 15 years inside Indonesian risk functions, I have come to see this asymmetry as worth naming. The structural questions underneath are the same the country has faced in commodities, manufacturing, and increasingly in technology talent. Value capture from human talent flows in Asia is a real economic question, not a cultural one.

What the Korean model does

Korean entertainment, particularly the major-agency tier, has built one of the most sophisticated talent recruitment, training, and IP capture systems in any creative industry globally.

  • Pre-debut investment scale. The major Korean agencies invest meaningfully (multiple years of housing, training, language education, performance development) into talent before commercial release. The investment is funded by the agency, capitalised on the agency’s balance sheet, and recovered through revenue-share contracts that run for years after debut.
  • Cross-border recruitment scaled to industrial level. Hearts2Hearts is one of many groups in the current generation with members from across Asia and beyond. The recruitment process is institutionalised: auditions across multiple countries, scouting networks, partnerships with local entertainment companies. Korean agencies capture talent before competing local industries do.
  • IP and revenue infrastructure designed to capture compound value. K-pop revenue is distributed across music, performance, advertising, merchandise, fan engagement platforms, content production, and licensing. The agencies control most of these revenue streams structurally. The talent’s share, while meaningful, is a fraction of the total economic activity their work generates.

Also Read: After Megaspeed, Indonesia pays the compliance bill for Asia’s AI chip race

Why the Indonesian industry captures less

Three structural factors limit how much value Indonesia captures from its own talent.

  • The development infrastructure gap. The training, performance development, and content production capability available in Indonesia is meaningfully smaller than what major Korean agencies offer. Indonesian artists who reach a certain stage often face a choice between the smaller domestic infrastructure or moving to where the larger infrastructure exists.
  • The IP and revenue model gap. Indonesian entertainment industry contracts, revenue distribution mechanisms, and IP infrastructure have not evolved as rapidly as the underlying market. Even when Indonesian artists achieve regional or international visibility, the share of value captured by Indonesian entities is structurally smaller than the equivalent in Korea or Japan.
  • The fan economy infrastructure gap. The platforms that monetise fan engagement at scale (fan communities, merchandise distribution, content subscriptions, ticketing) are predominantly built by non-Indonesian actors. Indonesian fans of Indonesian artists frequently engage through platforms that capture value outside Indonesia.

Lessons learned

Five principles emerge from observing the asymmetry.

  • Talent infrastructure is economic infrastructure. The countries that build serious training, development, and IP capture systems retain economic value from their talent. The countries that do not export the talent and absorb the leakage.
  • The cross-border talent flow is structural, not preventable. Indonesian talent will continue to move where infrastructure is more developed. The question is not whether the flow happens; it is whether Indonesia builds the infrastructure that captures part of the value before the flow.
  • Revenue model design matters more than talent quality. Indonesia has produced and continues to produce world-class musical and performance talent. The constraint is not talent quality. It is the contract structure, IP framework, and revenue infrastructure that captures the value the talent generates.
  • Cultural export requires institutional infrastructure. Korean entertainment did not become dominant globally by accident. It is the product of three decades of deliberate institutional investment: agencies, training systems, content infrastructure, government coordination, IP frameworks. Indonesia’s equivalent investment has been more episodic and less coordinated.
  • The next generation can change the curve. The infrastructure gap is not destiny. New platforms, models, and institutional approaches can move Indonesia’s value capture position over a five- to 10-year horizon. But the move requires deliberate building, not passive consumption of whatever model others have built.

Also Read: Entering Indonesia? The tax issues startups underestimate

The macro stakes

Asia’s entertainment industry economics are reshaping faster than most policy frameworks recognise. Korean entertainment is now a significant export category for Korea. Indonesia’s larger population and market potential make the underdevelopment of its entertainment industry infrastructure a more consequential gap than the others in the region.

Hearts2Hearts and the cohort of Korean groups with multinational members will continue to emerge. Indonesian artists, including No Na and others, will continue to navigate between markets. The question is whether the institutional infrastructure to capture more of the value of Indonesian talent (for Indonesia) gets built deliberately in the next decade, or whether the asymmetry continues to widen. The talent geography question is not going to answer itself.

—

Editor’s note: e27 aims to foster thought leadership by publishing views from the community. You can also share your perspective by submitting an article, video, podcast, or infographic.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of e27.

Join us on WhatsApp, Instagram, Facebook, X, and LinkedIn to stay connected.

The post Indonesia exports its talent, Korea captures the value: The K-pop lesson Jakarta can’t ignore appeared first on e27.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *