Posted on — Leave a comment

The quiet identity crisis behind AI productivity gains

My work in organisational psychology and clinical practice has increasingly brought me into conversations about how AI is changing people’s sense of professional identity.

One client, whose identifying details have been changed to protect confidentiality, leads a research team at a Singapore fintech company. AI has transformed how she works. Reports that once required hours of analysis can now be produced in minutes, leaving her more time to review findings, interpret results and make decisions.

Her productivity has improved considerably, but the nature of her contribution has changed. Much of the work through which she previously developed and demonstrated her expertise is now completed by AI.

Her experience raises an interesting psychological question: when the tasks that helped establish our professional identity begin to disappear, how does that change our sense of competence and achievement?

What the productivity figures leave out

According to Microsoft’s 2026 Work Trend Index, 66 per cent of AI users in Singapore report producing work they could not have created a year earlier, compared with 58 per cent globally.

For businesses looking to scale, these are impressive gains. Figures like these make their way into boardroom discussions and strategic planning. Few organisations are examining what happens to employees’ sense of competence as the nature of their contribution changes.

A 2025 study published in Scientific Reports, involving 3,562 participants across four experiments, found that working with generative AI improved immediate task performance. However, participants who subsequently returned to independent tasks reported lower intrinsic motivation and greater boredom.

Interestingly, their sense of control increased when they resumed working independently.

We develop our professional identity partly through effortful mastery. Solving difficult problems, making decisions and seeing the results of our own thinking provide evidence of what we are capable of.

When AI begins performing tasks through which people previously demonstrated those abilities, the experience of achievement can change, even when the quality of their work improves.

Also Read: Is prompt engineering real AI development, or just good documentation?

When confidence begins to erode

Research from Microsoft and Carnegie Mellon University surveyed 319 knowledge workers who regularly used generative AI. Greater confidence in AI was associated with less reported critical thinking effort, while confidence in one’s own abilities was associated with more.

The findings don’t establish that AI causes skills to deteriorate. They do, however, raise questions about what happens when people have fewer opportunities to exercise their abilities independently.

In psychology, self-efficacy describes our belief in our ability to perform a particular task. That belief develops partly through experience. We become confident in our abilities because we have repeatedly demonstrated them to ourselves.

Someone who rarely completes a complex assignment independently may gradually become less certain they can still do it. That uncertainty can encourage further reliance on AI, leaving fewer opportunities to practise.

Over time, this could create a cycle in which increasing dependence on technology makes independent performance feel more difficult, even as overall productivity continues to improve.

When success no longer feels like your own

The imposter phenomenon traditionally describes capable people who struggle to internalise their achievements, often attributing success to luck or external circumstances.

AI introduces a related question about how people understand their contribution to successful outcomes.

Someone might produce excellent work with AI assistance while becoming less certain which parts of the process reflect their own expertise. If the technology takes over much of the initial analysis, writing or problem-solving, the experience of achievement may also change.

Also Read: What’s actually changing for Asia Pacific businesses in the age of AI

The psychological implications are worth exploring. Professional identity develops through repeated experiences of competence, recognition and personal accomplishment. When those experiences change, people may need to reconsider how they understand their contribution.

From a clinical perspective, I am interested in how people maintain a sense of self-efficacy when the skills they have spent years developing are being used differently.

Rather than assuming that reassurance will address these concerns, there is value in exploring which aspects of someone’s work still depend on their expertise, where their judgement adds value and how they can continue developing their abilities.

In Microsoft’s Singapore findings, 52 per cent of respondents identified critical thinking as the most important human skill for an AI-enabled workplace. Employees appear to recognise the importance of retaining the capabilities that allow them to evaluate, challenge and improve what technology produces.

The difficulty comes when organisations celebrate those capabilities while designing work that gives people fewer opportunities to use them.

What leaders can do

For founders and business leaders, this presents a challenge alongside productivity targets. As AI changes how work gets done, organisations need to consider how people continue developing a sense of mastery and professional value.

  • Protect some independent thinking. Not every task needs to be completed at maximum speed. Teams can deliberately preserve opportunities for employees to analyse information, develop arguments or solve problems without AI assistance. Regular independent practice helps people maintain and develop their abilities.
  • Make human judgement visible. When AI produces much of the initial output, recognising performance becomes more complicated. Leaders should acknowledge the decisions employees make, the errors they catch and the improvements they introduce. These contributions can be substantial, even when they are less obvious than the volume of work produced.
  • Talk openly about changing roles. Only 24 per cent of Singapore respondents in Microsoft’s research reported clear and consistent leadership alignment on AI. When leaders remain vague about what technological change means for employees, people are left to draw their own conclusions. Be clear about what expertise looks like in an AI-enabled role, which skills remain essential and how professional development will continue.

For startups, where responsibilities can evolve rapidly as businesses grow, these conversations are particularly relevant. The pressure to move faster should leave room for people to develop alongside the technology.

Hours saved, and what fills them

AI offers organisations substantial opportunities to improve performance, and many employees are already benefiting from the time and resources it saves.

Yet as technology changes the process of working, it can also influence how people experience accomplishment. Autonomy, mastery and the ability to recognise our own progress contribute to sustained motivation and engagement.

These are aspects of working life that deserve consideration as organisations redesign roles and expectations around AI.

The hours saved are easy to measure. Changes in how people experience their own professional competence are considerably harder to detect.

AI can give teams back hours. Leaders should also consider what those hours are being replaced with, and whether employees still have opportunities to feel proud of what they bring to work.

—

Editor’s note: e27 aims to foster thought leadership by publishing views from the community. You can also share your perspective by submitting an article, video, podcast, or infographic.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of e27.

Join us on WhatsApp, Instagram, Facebook, X, and LinkedIn to stay connected.

The post The quiet identity crisis behind AI productivity gains appeared first on e27.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *