
When Americans go to the polls on November 3, much of the attention will be on which party controls Congress, but for corporate America, the more consequential question may be what happens after the votes are counted.
Affordability has become a defining issue in the 2026 midterm elections; from groceries and housing to healthcare and electricity, American households remain concerned about the cost of everyday life. An October Pew Research Center survey found that 84 percent of registered voters considered the economy very important to their midterm vote.
Politicians are under pressure to respond, yet businesses are increasingly drawn into the same debate. Companies can point to higher input costs, supply chain disruptions and geopolitical uncertainty to explain rising prices. Many of these pressures are genuine, but consumers and policymakers are asking another question: when companies report strong profits, are customers sharing in the benefits?
The midterms may shape Congress, but the affordability debate will continue beyond Election Day. For American businesses, it is becoming a test of corporate accountability.
From political issue to corporate responsibility
Affordability has traditionally been viewed as a government responsibility. Policymakers manage inflation and regulate markets, while businesses focus on profitability and competitiveness. However, that distinction is becoming harder to sustain.
Penta Group’s latest US policymaker research found that 64 percent identified the economy as their top issue, the first time that figure has exceeded 60 percent in 15 years. Importantly, 56 percent attributed affordability challenges primarily to macroeconomic or geopolitical forces, while 30 percent pointed to companies prioritising profits.
These findings reveal an important distinction. Policymakers recognise that businesses do not control every factor driving higher prices, but they increasingly distinguish between companies that contributed to the problem, those that benefited from it, and those helping consumers manage the consequences.
This scrutiny crosses political lines – Republicans have emphasised making everyday life affordable, while Democrats have questioned whether corporate pricing practices place excessive burdens on consumers. The approaches differ, but both reflect growing expectations that businesses demonstrate how their decisions affect household finances.
When profits and affordability collide
The tension becomes particularly visible when companies report healthy earnings while consumers struggle with essential expenses.
Between September 2020 and September 2026, overall US consumer prices rose by approximately 29 percent, according to Bureau of Labor Statistics data. Although inflation has moderated from earlier peaks, households still face substantially higher prices for everyday goods and services.
Also Read: Why I filed a consumer complaint against 7 global AI giants over the ‘linguistic tax’
Yet the debate is not simply about rising prices; it is increasingly about who benefits when economic conditions improve.
Consider the debate over tariff refunds following the US Supreme Court’s February decision invalidating tariffs imposed under emergency economic powers. Costco pledged to return the value of recovered tariffs to members through lower prices and better value, while FedEx and UPS committed to refunding customers who had paid applicable tariff charges. Other organisations have been non-committal about how customers will benefit from those very refunds.
The controversy raises a broader question: when businesses recover costs previously borne by consumers, how much of that benefit should they pass back?
Companies may have legitimate reasons to retain some gains, including recovering earlier losses or funding investment. But they should be prepared to explain their decisions. The issue is not whether companies should make profits, it is whether commercial success delivers demonstrable value for customers.
Affordability is also about access and fairness
Price alone does not determine whether consumers regard a company as fair. Increasingly, affordability also depends on access, transparency, and whether customers feel they are receiving reasonable value.
Airlines illustrate this tension. Premium cabins, priority boarding, and additional services are legitimate ways to differentiate products and generate revenue, but when basic fares become increasingly restrictive, with extra charges for baggage, seat selection, and other services, consumers may question whether the advertised price reflects the real cost of travel.
The concern is not that premium experiences exist; it is whether businesses are improving choice or gradually making previously standard services available only to those willing to pay more. There is a difference between making premium experiences more attractive and making ordinary experiences less accessible. Across industries, businesses risk reputational damage when pursuing higher-value customers comes at the expense of affordability for everyone else.
Technology introduces another complication. Artificial intelligence (AI) offers opportunities to reduce costs and improve productivity, yet increasingly sophisticated personalised pricing raises questions about whether companies might use consumer data to charge different customers different prices for comparable services.
For policymakers, these practices raise concerns beyond inflation, extending to competition, consumer protection, and corporate governance.
Also Read: The consumer is still human. The gatekeeper isn’t
Proof matters more than promises
The answer is not for companies to sacrifice profitability or absorb every cost increase, but to demonstrate that commercial success and consumer value can go hand in hand. That requires businesses to assess how pricing, fees, and product decisions affect different customer groups, especially those with fewer alternatives, and to identify opportunities to deliver value while sustaining growth. They should also demonstrate tangible benefits. If supply chain improvements reduce costs, are savings passed on? If automation improves efficiency, does it make services more accessible? Are affordable options preserved?
Boardrooms should treat affordability as part of discussions about reputation, regulation, and long-term competitiveness, not simply as a communications challenge. Penta’s policymaker research offers an instructive example. Multiple policymakers across party lines independently identified Costco as an affordability leader. Respondents pointed to its reputation for competitive prices, relatively low margins and focus on customer experience.
That recognition reflects consistent business practices rather than a single marketing campaign. Credibility comes from what businesses do, not simply what they say.
Beyond November
The implications extend beyond the United States. American debates about corporate pricing, consumer protection, and responsible AI use can shape international regulatory expectations, including among multinationals operating in Asia.
Companies that treat affordability as somebody else’s responsibility risk greater consumer skepticism and regulatory scrutiny. Those that show their decisions preserve access, improve transparency, and deliver value will be better positioned to maintain trust.
Businesses may not be responsible for every increase in the cost of living, but they will increasingly be judged by how they respond to rising affordability pressures. The midterms will determine who holds political power in Washington, but the affordability debate will continue to shape how policymakers, consumers, and other stakeholders assess the way corporate America exercises its economic power.
Co-authored together with Bryan DeAngelis and Tucker Warren, Senior Partners, Penta Group
—
Editor’s note: e27 aims to foster thought leadership by publishing views from the community. You can also share your perspective by submitting an article, video, podcast, or infographic.
The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of e27.
Join us on WhatsApp, Instagram, Facebook, X, and LinkedIn to stay connected.
The post America’s affordability election is becoming corporate America’s accountability test appeared first on e27.
