
A customer orders a product online, receives it and requests a refund. From the buyer’s perspective, the process may involve a few taps and a parcel handed to a courier. For the merchant, it can initiate a second supply chain involving transportation, inspection, reimbursement, inventory recovery and additional administrative work.
This matters in Southeast Asia, where e-commerce gross merchandise value is projected to reach US$226 billion in 2026, according to the latest Google, Temasek and Bain e-Conomy SEA report. While marketplaces compete to make purchasing easier, retailers must also manage the economics of transactions that do not become completed sales.
Returns are therefore more than a customer-service expense. They represent a commercial commitment whose actual cost depends on product margins, logistics infrastructure, payment arrangements and the ability to recover inventory value.
The refund is only the visible part of the financial loss
A conventional order-level profitability calculation subtracts product costs, marketplace commissions, payment fees, fulfilment expenses and customer acquisition costs from retained revenue. Once an order is returned, however, several additional expenses enter the calculation.
The original shipment may already have consumed transportation and packaging resources. The merchant may then incur collection charges, inspection costs, repackaging expenses and customer-service work. Depending on marketplace rules and contractual arrangements, some commissions and payment fees may be reversed while others remain payable. The financial burden can also be distributed differently between the merchant, platform and logistics provider.
Consider a hypothetical retailer earning US$5 in contribution margin on a successfully completed order but losing US$9 when an order is returned, after accounting for recoverable inventory value and processing costs. At a 10 per cent return rate, expected contribution is US$3.60 per order. At 25 per cent, it falls to US$1.50. These figures are illustrative rather than regional estimates, but they demonstrate how return frequency affects profitability.
The important measurement is expected contribution across retained and returned transactions. Refunds should not be counted twice by treating reversed sales revenue and the refund itself as separate losses. Equally, recovered inventory should not automatically be valued as though it were ready for immediate resale.
Also Read: The invisible shopper rewriting Asia’s e-commerce playbook
Southeast Asia does not operate through one logistics model
The economic consequences of a return vary substantially across regional markets. Recovering a parcel within Singapore’s dense urban environment is different from collecting one across Indonesia’s islands or from a remote Philippine location. Transportation distances, carrier networks, consolidation capacity and warehouse accessibility influence the cost of moving goods backward.
Payment arrangements introduce another distinction. Cash-on-delivery transactions can generate failed deliveries when customers refuse parcels before payment, leaving the operator with transportation costs but no completed sale. These incidents differ from returns initiated after receiving and paying for merchandise. Although cash on delivery is declining across Southeast Asia, its continued relevance differs between countries, making a single regional assumption inappropriate.
Cross-border commerce creates additional complexity. An inexpensive product may be profitable to ship internationally through consolidated outbound deliveries but uneconomical to return individually. Depending on product value, contractual conditions and applicable consumer protections, a merchant might choose local resale, liquidation, replacement or a refund without physical recovery.
The cheapest logistical option is not necessarily the most profitable. A retailer must compare transportation costs with recoverable product value, inventory availability and the operational consequences of each alternative. Reverse logistics should consequently be designed around product characteristics and destination markets rather than treated as a simple reversal of outbound delivery.
Recovering the product does not mean recovering its value
Returned merchandise must be inspected before its economic value can be determined. An unopened product may qualify for immediate resale, while another requires repackaging, refurbishment or a substantial discount. Some products cannot be sold again under their original commercial conditions.
These differences become particularly important across categories. Apparel may require condition checks and repackaging. Consumer electronics can involve functionality testing, warranty assessment and potential depreciation. Damaged or hygiene-sensitive products may retain little recoverable value despite the cost of transporting them back.
Time also affects profitability. Merchandise undergoing collection and inspection remains unavailable for sale, potentially creating inventory shortages even when returned stock physically exists elsewhere in the network. Seasonal products and rapidly depreciating items may lose value while operators decide how to process them. Refunds can additionally create a working-capital gap before any resale proceeds are received.
An effective recovery decision therefore compares the net proceeds available through different channels. Returning an inexpensive item to a central warehouse may cost more than selling it through a local liquidation partner. Refund-without-return arrangements can sometimes reduce expenses, but poorly controlled policies also introduce fraud risks, inventory discrepancies and avoidable waste.
The objective is not to recover every parcel. It is to determine which recovery process preserves the greatest economic value after all associated costs.
Also Read: Profitable e-commerce: Making real money in the new year
Return policies influence conversion as well as profitability
Restricting returns may appear attractive when reverse-logistics expenses rise. However, a return policy also influences purchasing behaviour. Customers buying unfamiliar products cannot physically examine them before payment, making the possibility of a refund part of the perceived security of the transaction.
Research published in the American Economic Journal: Microeconomics in 2024 examines this tension between the costs generated by returns and the efficiency gained when consumers can evaluate products after purchase. From a retailer’s perspective, a generous policy can therefore produce benefits through greater willingness to buy, even while increasing operational expenses.
The commercial calculation must account for both effects. Reducing return eligibility could lower processing costs while discouraging customers whose purchases depend on reassurance. Conversely, making every return exceptionally convenient may increase conversion without generating sufficient additional contribution to cover the resulting expenses.
Preventing avoidable returns can be more effective than introducing blanket restrictions. Accurate sizing information, realistic product images, technical compatibility details and stronger seller-quality controls address causes of dissatisfaction before an order is placed. Policies should distinguish legitimate product defects from preference-based returns while respecting consumer rights and marketplace obligations.
The question is not simply whether returns should be free. It is whether the purchasing confidence generated by a particular policy creates enough additional economic value to justify its complete cost.
Profitability must be measured after the reverse journey
Managing these economics requires connecting information that frequently sits in separate operational systems. Order records identify the original sale, payment systems record settlements, logistics providers track movements, and warehouse systems establish whether returned merchandise can be resold.
Retailers need a consistent view of these events. Return rates should distinguish items returned after delivery from failed deliveries and cancellations, with clearly defined denominators. Recovery value, time to refund, processing expenses and contribution margin should be analysed by product category, sales channel, carrier and destination.
This creates a more useful basis for evaluating marketplace relationships. The organisation deciding how attractive a return policy should appear is not necessarily the organisation financing its execution. Shipping subsidies, seller-liability rules and reimbursement arrangements can create different economic incentives across the same transaction.
For sellers, understanding this allocation is essential when deciding whether a channel remains profitable. For marketplaces, it helps identify situations where additional purchasing convenience generates costs elsewhere in the network.
The underlying challenge is not to make returns difficult for customers or to eliminate them indiscriminately. It is to build a system capable of providing reliable remedies while recovering inventory value efficiently and maintaining sustainable margins.
Southeast Asian e-commerce has developed increasingly sophisticated capabilities for attracting customers and delivering products. Its next profitability challenge also lies in understanding what happens when those products travel in the opposite direction. Growth measured through merchandise value tells only part of the story. The economic result emerges after the entire transaction, including the possibility of its reversal, has been accounted for.
—
Editor’s note: e27 aims to foster thought leadership by publishing views from the community. You can also share your perspective by submitting an article, video, podcast, or infographic.
The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of e27.
Join us on WhatsApp, Instagram, Facebook, X, and LinkedIn to stay connected.
The post The hidden economics of returns in Southeast Asian e-commerce appeared first on e27.
