Posted on

GenAI’s twisted impact on the creative world: Navigating chaos to find new order

“In the ever-evolving technology landscape…” — If you are an avid consumer of business content, I’m sure you encounter this phrase quite a bit these days! The phrase has become the de-facto opening for many B2B blogs, particularly after 2022 — the milestone year ChatGPT was introduced. The GenAI tool helped both writers and non-writers alike to escape the dreaded blank page. In doing so, it has unleashed a certain homogeneity that can put us off and might even lead us to suspect that the content is AI-generated. 

Gen AI’s twisted impact on creative content

AI tools no longer belong to just the techies and geeks. Today, we have a flurry of AI tools across writing, graphic design, product design, fashion design, photography, music, podcasts, and video production. These tools don’t just provide a decent starting point but also assist users at every stage, accelerating their creative production process.

Tools such as DALL-E, Mid-journey, and ChatGPT have dramatically sped up traditionally time-consuming design processes. Adobe’s recent move to add GenAI capabilities, enabling image creation using simple text prompts, seems like a significant step forward.  What’s interesting is Adobe intends to pay the original creators of those stock images.

And here is a game changer for music enthusiasts and creators. Aviva — an AI music-generation assistant allows you to generate new songs in more than 250 different styles in a matter of seconds. On the visual side, Luma AI’s dream machine, which is now open to the public, generates realistic and aesthetic AI videos from text and images. 

Many exclaim these tools are democratising access to professional-level creativity.

But here is the twist! If GenAI drives a never-before-seen acceleration in meaningful content production, it also contributes to AI-generated noise that lacks flavour or nuance or an authentic creative flair that catches the eye. 

Think about it — if everyone is using the same AI tools, trained on similar datasets — how would the content truly stand out, unless obviously that content — be it text, image, or video is embedded with a unique human voice? 

Entity Chaos  New order 
Content A sea of AI-generated noise lacking unique flavour, originality, depth, and context. Accelerate the creation of meaningful, quality, relevant, and high-impact content. 

How can GeAI solutions solve chaos and amplify new order?

Entity Tackling chaos  Amplifying new order 
Content
  • AI personalisation tools: Platforms that allow creators to train AI models with their unique style or voice, ensuring distinct outputs.
  • Content quality verifiers: AI tools that assess originality and creativity in content before distribution.
AI-enhanced collaboration agents: They act as co-workers, providing integrated suggestions for the whole team.

GenAI’s twisted impact on the creative workforce

Unlike other innovations in the past, which have fundamentally automated mundane, repetitive work, GenAI is inherently a creative tool that promises to automate creativity, albeit in parts. For many professional creators, the entry of GenAI was confusing. They initially demonstrated a viscerally negative reaction, but a couple of years down the time, they have begun to realise the positive impact it has on their work. 

A recent online survey by 99designs, involving 10,000 freelance designers, highlights a significant positive shift in attitudes toward generative AI as the technology becomes mainstream. The study reveals that 52 per cent of designers now use generative AI tools, up from 39 per cent in 2023. Notably, 39 per cent of respondents believe AI will positively influence their careers in the long run, compared to 29 per cent who fear it may have a negative impact. 

But once again, let me introduce the sinister twist here: The 29 per cent seem to be right, because according to Harvard Business Review, there has been a 17 per cent drop in jobs tending to visual design in the past year. Writers on the other hand faced a 30% reduction in jobs in the same year. The research clearly says the trend is likely to continue as AI would not just be a helpful assistant but also replace some of the creative jobs spanning writing, imaging, and even software coding. 

Also Read: Revolutionising retail: A blueprint for future success

Based on the above we can draw two possible conclusions:

  • Experienced creators increasingly view AI as a creative ally. They use the tool predominantly for idea generation, gaining a head-start into projects as well as completing low-stakes iterative tasks, where the output can be easily verified. 
  • Beginners, on the other hand, might be finding it tricky to surpass business leaders and decision makers  who increasingly believe that GenAI  minimises the need for a larger creative workforce. 
Entity Chaos  New order 
Creative Workforce  Decline in creative jobs due to automation.  Experienced creators increasingly see AI as a creative ally for ideation and handling repetitive tasks.

How can GenAI solutions solve chaos and amplify new order among the creative workforce?

Entity  Tackling chaos  Amplifying new order 
Creative Workforce  Creativity-augmenting AI: Brainstorming assistants and conceptual visualisation tools that enhance human creativity rather than replace it. Customisable AI tools: AI systems allowing experienced creators to embed personal preferences, making AI more aligned with their unique style.

GenAI — A friend or foe to the future workforce? 

Though many educators still believe GenAI is the wild wild west, it’s hard to miss that the technology has quietly become a staple in most students’ academic tool kit. Research highlights that 86 per cent of today’s students — the future workforce — already use GenAI in their studies, with 25 per cent doing so every day. 

GenAI has shown tremendous potential to personalise student learning and spark creative exploration. However, the biggest concern most educators/evaluators have is that students use the tool to instantly complete their assignments with the least effort. Gen Y and Gen X teachers, who have seen the transition from traditional to technology-based learning, fear students might become over reliant on the technology, losing their critical problem solving skills and the ability to think independently. This is what some students report as a “fixation of the mind”– inability to think beyond AI ideas and generate original concepts.  

This calls for a thoughtful and balanced approach to integrating AI into classrooms, presenting a promising opportunity for businesses to develop novel generative AI solutions tailored to education. 

Entity Chaos  New order 
Students/Future Workforce  Over-reliance on AI tools, leading to reduced original thought and creativity; “fixation of the mind”on AI ideas. Personalised learning and creative exploration opportunities with GenAI.

How can GenAI solutions solve chaos and amplify new order among the future workforce?

Entity  Tackling chaos  Amplifying new order 
Students/Future Workforce 
  • Gamified learning platforms: Games that challenge students to generate original ideas before providing AI support.
  • Educational AI integration kits: Kits that enable schools to integrate AI tools responsibly, teaching students how to collaborate effectively with AI.
Adaptive AI learning platforms: AI-driven platforms that customise learning paths based on student performance.

Manipulated media — GenAI’s twisted impact on content consumption

Instagram, which helps millions of influencers monetise their content, is witnessing a proliferation of AI-generated influencers. These AI personas are stealing videos from real models, replacing faces with AI generated ones to create deepfakes. Ultimately, they profit from these manipulated videos by  linking them to dating platforms and various AI-based apps. While genuine human influencers will now have to compete with AI-generated influencers, the bigger concern is the ramifications on consumers. Could they be misled in dangerous ways? 

In an effort to curb misinformation before the election, Meta, earlier this year, proactively began tagging social media content using the “Made with AI” labels. However, soon after when multiple meta users complained that their human-generated images were incorrectly labeled, the company changed to a more subtle “AI info” label. 

We are seeing a clear tug of war between the proliferation of deepfake content and their detection. As deepfake capabilities continue to evolve, it opens up significant opportunities for enterprises and Independent Software Vendors (ISVs) to innovate. They can develop generative AI solutions that empower consumers to proactively flag AI-generated content, helping steer media consumption away from misinformation and disinformation. 

Also Read: Singapore aims to lead in AI — but where’s the talent?

But not everything is sinister with GenAI in the media. 

Daisy, an AI granny, attempts to strike a balance by scam-baiting hackers. The revolutionary human-like chatbot works by answering calls in real-time, mimicking human conversations to make hackers believe they are conversing with a human, when in fact, Daisy would be wasting the scammer’s time, ultimately reducing the number of scams attempted. 

Even deepfakes as a technology has shown to have tremendous potential to create content otherwise not feasible. It has been employed in production to de-age actors, synchronise actors’ lip sync and movements in multiple languages, and even bring historical figures to life. 

Gen AI Chaos  New order 
Media   Proliferation of AI influencers and deepfakes; misinformation and disinformation spreading via manipulated media. Novel uses in production (e.g., de-aging actors, synchronising multilingual lip-syncs); tools like Daisy scam-baiting hackers to curb scams.

How can GenAI solutions solve chaos and amplify new order in media 

Entity  Tacking chaos  Amplifying new order 
Media  
  • AI deepfake detectors: Advanced detection tools like Microsoft Video Authenticator for verifying content authenticity.
  • Blockchain for content provenance: Using blockchain to track the origin of media and verify its authenticity.
  • Ethical AI influencer platforms: Platforms that certify and showcase genuine human influencers and ethical AI-generated content.
  • AI-powered production suites: Comprehensive platforms combining tools for de-aging, lip-syncing, and historical recreations (e.g., Adobe AI Suite).
  • Ethical AI content certifications: Systems to certify ethically created AI-enhanced media, building audience trust.
  • Immersive AI studios: AI tools for creating immersive, real-time virtual environments for film and media production.

Here’s a technical low down on how the AI models mimic human creativity

AI models  How models generate new data  How humans create
Traditional autoencoders 

 

  • Compress data into a smaller latent space and reconstruct it.
  • Identify patterns but don’t create new content.
  • Analyse and summarise ideas based on their importance.
  • Recall details from memory to reconstruct a concept.
Variation autoencoders 
  • Add randomness to the latent space, allowing for the generation of new data close to what it has learned.
  • Imagine variations of known ideas or concepts.
  • Use intuition to create something new but familiar.
Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs)
  • Generate new data by combining learned patterns, evaluated by a discriminator for realism.
  • Trial and error: Humans create something and assess its quality themselves or seek feedback from others.
Stable Diffusion Models
  • Start with random noise and refine it step-by-step, guided by patterns from training data and external conditions (e.g., text prompts).
  • Start with a vague idea and progressively clarify and refine it based on goals, feedback, and personal judgment.
Deep Sequence Models 
  • Learn and predict patterns in sequences (e.g., text or time-series data).
  • Generate new sequences by extending learned patterns.
  • Follow logical or chronological steps when writing, composing, or thinking, while adding creativity along the way.
Transformers 
  • Use self-attention to weigh the importance of elements in input data and generate coherent outputs
  • Focus on important details of a concept or idea while considering context and relationships between elements.

Twisted for a good reason

While Generative AI is here to stay, it is all set to disrupt, cause chaos, and eventually enable a new order. This transformation opens a fresh set of opportunities for ISVs and enterprises to create novel GenAI solutions that could go a long way in enabling creators and non-creators  to preserve and promote creative expression.

With regard to individual creators, GenAI has democratised creativity, making it more accessible to all. But, can an ordinary individual using GenAI tools truly match or exceed the work of a seasoned creative professional?

Well, that’s ultimately left to the subjective human judgment. As they say, beauty lies in the eyes of the beholder! However, I truly believe that as long as humans are the audience, creative professionals will likely maintain an edge in crafting resonant, meaningful content that speaks directly to human emotions. 

Editor’s note: e27 aims to foster thought leadership by publishing views from the community. Share your opinion by submitting an article, video, podcast, or infographic.

Join us on InstagramFacebookX, and LinkedIn to stay connected.

Image courtesy: Canva Pro

The post GenAI’s twisted impact on the creative world: Navigating chaos to find new order appeared first on e27.